Case study · Lakewood, CO

Jewelry store SEO: from 4 calls a month to 77, straight from Google

Mustache Gold & Silver buys and sells gold, silver, coins and jewelry in Lakewood, Colorado, and was hard to find on Google. We built their website and run their Google Business Profile. In July, the profile alone sent 77 phone calls.

  • 77 calls from Google in July
  • 19× last July’s calls
  • #1 in Maps for 4 core searches
  • 4.7★ from 55 reviews
Illustration of a Techy Toes character holding a map pin
Display cases inside a jewelry store

Phone calls from Google, July against July

Calls rose from 4 to 77, the same month a year apart, so the season is the same on both sides. These are calls made by tapping the number on their Google listing: not website visits, not impressions.

July 2025Before 4
July 2026With the new site and profile work 77
Google Business Profile performance for Mustache Gold and Silver, July 2026: 77 calls made from the Business Profile, up 1,825% on July 2025, with a daily chart across the month.
Google reports July 2026 as 77 calls, up 1,825% on July 2025, which is 4 calls. Calls from the listing are only part of the picture: people who find the shop on Maps also ask for directions and simply walk in, and neither shows up as a call.

First in Maps for the searches that bring sellers in

The shop is first in Google Maps for all four searches below, run live from its own neighbourhood on 24 September 2026.

  • Google Maps search

    “sell gold near me”

    1. Mustache Gold & SilverClient 4.7★ · 55 reviews
    2. A national jewelry chain 4.7★ · 494 reviews
    3. A second national chain 4.7★ · 187 reviews

    Ahead of two national chains with nine and three times the reviews.

  • Google Maps search

    “gold buyer near me”

    1. Mustache Gold & SilverClient 4.7★ · 55 reviews
    2. An appointment-only diamond buyer No reviews

    The search that most directly means "I have gold to sell today".

  • Google Maps search

    “coin shop near me”

    1. Mustache Gold & SilverClient 4.7★ · 55 reviews
    2. A metaphysical and gift shop 4.8★ · 141 reviews
    3. A coin-counting kiosk No reviews

    Collectors searching for a real coin dealer find one first.

  • Google Maps search

    “silver buyers near me”

    1. Mustache Gold & SilverClient 4.7★ · 55 reviews

    The only business Google shows for this search from the shop’s area.

Map rankings depend on where the searcher is standing, so these are the results near the shop: the customers most likely to visit. Other businesses are described rather than named.

What we did: one website, one Google profile, managed together

We built mustachegoldandsilver.com and manage both it and the Google Business Profile. Four pieces, in the order they matter.

  1. Built the website around what people want to sell

    Separate pages for what they buy and what they sell (gold, silver and platinum jewelry, diamonds, coins, bars and bullion), plus a plain-English walkthrough of how a visit works, so a first-time seller knows what to expect before walking in.

  2. A page for every town they serve

    Lakewood, Applewood, Golden, Wheat Ridge and Arvada each have their own page, so the site answers the searches people in those towns actually make instead of one page trying to cover all of them.

  3. Set up and run the Google Business Profile

    Categories that match every reason someone might visit (gold dealer, coin dealer, jewelry buyer, diamond buyer) and the same name, address, phone and hours on the profile as on the site. This is the half that produces the calls.

  4. Ongoing SEO on both

    We manage the profile and the website together, month to month, because Google checks one against the other. A profile pointing at a thin website ranks worse than one pointing at a site that confirms everything it says.

From almost no search visibility to 86 ranking keywords

Semrush's estimate of the website's organic reach. In October 2025 the site ranked for almost nothing; by September 2026 it ranked for 86 keywords, up 65% on its previous reading.

86

Organic keywords (+65%)

136

Estimated organic visits a month (+15%)

226

Referring domains

Semrush domain overview for mustachegoldandsilver.com: organic traffic 136 (up 15%), 86 organic keywords (up 65%), 226 referring domains, with traffic and keyword charts rising from October 2025 to September 2026.
Semrush figures are third-party estimates, not the site's own analytics.

What's next: winning the website results, not just the map

The map pack is won near the shop. The next job is the ordinary search results beneath it.

The website still sits outside the first page for broad searches like "sell gold near me". That is where buyers from further across the west Denver suburbs look, and it is what the monthly SEO work is aimed at now.

See also: Fence contractor SEO case study · Google Business Profile optimization · Website design

Want to know where you rank on the map?

Tell us your business and the searches that matter. We will check where you actually appear in Google Maps from your own neighbourhood and tell you what is holding you back.